
Interesting times we are in as fans of the Seattle Seahawks. At the midpoint of this season, the team rests at a disappointing 4-4 record, and many (if not most) fans are now excited to get their wish of seeing Drew Lock in at quarterback instead of Sam Darnold, who since coming back in week three from his glute injury he suffered in the season opener, has looked a shadow of himself apart from a game two weeks ago against the Kansas City Chiefs.
It stands to reason right now that Sam is going to go down as one of the oddest storylines in franchise history at the quarterback position. He has done what only one other quarterback as done in the 51 year history of the team, and that is to lead a top five explosive offense matched with a top of the pack defense to the Super Bowl title. Yet fans had been reluctant to embrace him in the year he accomplished this feat, and they are ready to move on from him now.
I am convinced that Sam could come back in a few weeks, step back into the QB1 gig, guide this team back into the playoffs, maybe get another win or two, and once this season is done, many fans will feel desperate to see him replaced in 2027. He doesn’t possess the “aura” that the cool kids want at quarterback, and I think that is very fair to say.
Even if the offensive line gels better with Quinton Nelson at left guard, and Grey Zabel moved over to the right, and Brian Fleury gets his shit together better as a play caller, and receivers get open better, and running backs run better, and Sam regains his 2024-2025 form as a passer, many fans will stay negatively dug in about him, and the moment this season is complete, they will hope and pray this team either trades for Justin Herbert this offseason, or spends their first round pick on a quarterback to come in and be the long term solution. I would assume that many would even convince themselves that Sam’s replacement is already on the roster with either 28 years old Drew Lock, or 23 year old third string quarterback Jalen Milroe.
This is where I feel we are as a fanbase with the Seahawks, for better or worse. There are some of us, like myself, that will hold a belief that it is highly unlikely that most of what troubles this offense rests on Sam Darnold, and a more experienced play caller would draw up better game plans to suit him, and the talent on this team, and we would see a very similar version of him as has been on display in the league for the past two seasons on two different teams, but then there are those who will just not have that take. They believe that Sam is absolute dumpster fire trash and needs to go. I have had robust back and forth exchanges with a few of these sorts this past week.
Well, now they have their wish. The team is holding out Sam week to week with cracked ribs and a quad injury after he was beaten to a pulp by a Bears defense that nobody could block on Monday Night Football. This Sunday, we will get sore elbowed Drew Lock in as QB1, and if he cannot stay on the field after his elbow flares up, we will have Jalen Milroe getting his first meaningful NFL action at quarterback against a scrappy Arizona Cardinals team that is suddenly feeling themselves with Gardner Minshew in at QB for them.
I have a very hard time imagining Minshew doing much against the Seahawks defense that will certainly be out for blood this weekend after what happened on Monday night, but then again, I didn’t really expect much from Marcus Mariota in Washington five games ago, either. I suspect that all Lock has to do is something fairly similar to what he did the last time these two division rivals met up in week two; he just needs to productively game manage and not put the ball in harms way, and Seattle will likely win this one even if it’s not as pretty of a victory as it was the first time around in September, a 17 to 9 sorta home victory outing would suffice.
Now, let me be the first to say that I really like Drew Lock. In fact, when the team first brought him in with Russell Wilson trade in 2022, I was one of several within the fanbase who wanted to see Pete Carroll give him an honest shot at the starter gig, and was initially disappointed to see Carroll go with Geno Smith, instead. While Geno eventually would win me over, I still held some intrigue with Drew, and I was at the MNF game against the Eagles in 2023 when he eventually had to fill in as a starter, and he guided Seattle to a fun upset win. I was also very happy to see Drew step onto the field in the season opener in replacement of an injured Darnold and guide Seattle to a narrow low scoring victory over the Patriots and then follow up that game with a strong game managing performance on the road against the Cardinals.
Drew has a skillset that remains intriguing. He’s tall and mobile, and he has an arm that is elastic and he can throw from a variety of angles. He is also very likable, and if you watch him in any of his press conferences, he beams out an energy of a guy who is very easy to be pulled to root for. I get it why so many fans want to see him as the starter now, and if he plays well over a two game stretch against two teams that don’t particularly have very good defenses, they won’t want to see Sam back in the lineup against the 49ers after a bye week. I am not sure I would want to see that, if Drew plays really well, either.
I am just very dubious to put a ton of faith into a 28 year old career backup coming in with an injured elbow that was sustained during a practice a few weeks back, and stepping out onto a field and playing lights out. I am not as excited as many fans are for this, and I will be honest, I’m a bit nervous. While I expect a win over the Cardinals, I also expect that the Cardinals will give this game their all after their upset win against the Cowboys, and if Brian Fleury’s play calling doesn’t improve, and the Cardinals defense throws everything at a sore elbowed Drew Lock, anything can happen in this match.
In short, it is not that I lack a severe amount of faith in Drew. It is that I hold an extreme lack of faith in Fleury, and I have written extensively over the past few weeks about that.
For my part, I would be much more excited this Sunday if Jalen Milroe were to be making his first professional start at quarterback, and I am not a huge Milroe believer. At least with Jalen, there would be an elite running threat at quarterback that could catch Arizona defenders off guard. Assuming that Fleury would have the wherewithal to adjust his playbook to suite Jalen on naked bootlegs, and such, if he rolls outside the pocket on the move, defenders would be forced to make uncomfortable decisions as to whether to abandon coverage to come up and meet him, or hang back and hope he throws. For a game, his presence under center could legitimately catch an NFL defense off guard, and open up a struggling run game in a very fun way.
If it works and Seattle wins comfortably, then he would get another opportunity perhaps to build off of such a performance in Vegas, and if that leads to yet another comfortable win with him throwing and running, well then. Perhaps Seattle would have a situation at quarterback that would liven up this fanbase thinking about not only the present, but the future, as well.
Here is the reality of this situation, however. Jalen Milroe is in year two of his four year rookie contract, and he has not been able to supplant Drew Lock at QB2 as the team has hoped he would be able to do by now. It could very well be that Drew is that good, but it could also very well be that Jalen remains that raw, still.
So, this is where we are with this team folks. We have a QB1 who has just won a Super Bowl and is only 29 years old, and many folks are now ready to see kicked to the curb in favor of a 28 year old career backup with a sore elbow situation, and we have a 23 year old third stringer with world class athleticism who the coaching staff is reluctant to have him start. Doesn’t feel overly appetizing of a situation for me as a fan, but what say you?
If Sam Darnold is not your guy, as he is clearly not for many now, what would you prefer this team do after this season concludes? What is your answer at quarterback.
Do you want to see this team kick Sam to curb, and re-sign Drew, and draft a quarterback to compete with Drew and Jalen Milroe through training camp?
Assuming that Seattle ends the season where they are record wise, in a somewhat .500-ish sort of way, they will be picking in the draft in the mid teens this Spring. There is an anticipation that their will be a number of quarterbacks going in round one this year, but none of these players are a bonafide superstar on the horizon Andrew Luck/Caleb Williams sort of player in college right now. They will likely be taken earlier that perhaps is warrants them to be taken like Cam Ward was a couple year back, and folks like Michael Penix and JJ McCarthy were selected, previously. If Seattle is picking at, say, 16 overall, they might be in a position to be missing out, and left with a decision as either reach for one (generally, a bad decision), or hope that there will be a player they like who they will be willing to take a crack at later like they did with Milroe in late round three back in 2025.
There is a few players in college that do intrigue me as a potential Seahawk QBOTF. Ole Miss QB Trinidad Chambliss has a bit of a Russell Wilson/Baker Mayfield sort of vibe to his game as a player who is shorter but has a big arm and twitch in the pocket to make plays on the run. Miami QB Darian Mensah is hyper efficient, seems to be fairly athletic, and has some height to him that feels translatable to the NFL, but he’s also playing on the most talented team in CFB right now, and it amens me wonder if he’s Brock Purdy as a distributor, or if he’s going to be Teddy Bridgewater as a pro. Oklahoma State Drew Mestemaker feels like the player in college who could legitimately become a star in the NFL but he is only twenty years old, and it is unclear if he would be willing to turn pro this Spring. Outside of these three guys, however, I haven’t been seeing a lot that would warrant spending a first round pick on quarterback if the Seahawks are aiming to take a QB this Spring. If they stay this course through this season, they will probably not be in an ideal spot in the pecking order to select one.
So, if there’s nobody in college who is going to be a realistic aim for Seattle in the draft, then what? Do you want to see a big massive trade for a veteran passer?
How does three first round picks and Sam Darnold to the Chargers in exchange for a struggling Justin Herbert sound?
Three first round picks will be the starting asking price from the Chargers and they have more of less said as much this week in reporting. Do you want to pay this price for a guy who has all kinds of physical talent but will be 29 years old next year, and has shown on numerous occasions in the playoffs to fold under pressure?
It would be a fun storyline to see him return to the PNW where he grew up and finish out his career. My wife and her family who are Duck fans would probably like this. How much better is Herbert over Darnold though, really? That’s the question to be honestly ask.
Physically, he’s a superior athlete, but is he a superior quarterback? Is he three first round picks more superior???
I like Justin Herbert a lot, but I cannot answer that question positively with any sort of certainty.
If not Herbert then do you want to John Schneider send two first round picks to Baltimore for Lamar Jackson who is injury prone, going to be 30 years old, and has no agent who represents him in contract talks, just him and his mom? Do you honestly want to entertain this? I do not.
How about four or five first round picks to Cincy for often injured Joe Burrow? How about this move if Seattle does this? I love Joe’s game, absolutely, but 9 gets injured A LOT as a player.
Like it or not, I don’t personally say a lot of sure fire ways for Seattle to move on from Sam Darnold and get a lot better at quarterback. I wish I did, but I do not.
Sure, they could trade of cut him this offseason if he continues to play subpar, and they can extend Drew and make him the starter and have Jalen and maybe a rookie in the wings. This could be a thing. I wouldn’t feel wildly optimistic, however, especially if they have not fixed the OC situation.
They could take a hyper aggressive big swing in a trade for a veteran QB. New ownership might even push for it as they might like to go into next offseason determined to appease the fanbase. We could see Herbert in Seattle, absolutely. He has a physical profile that Schneider has always been drawn towards. He’s big and athletic, and has a monster arm. It is troubling to have seen him on multiple occasions fold terribly in the playoffs, however, and for those who will forever hold onto “Sam seeing ghosts,” I don’t know how they can suddenly get excited and look past all of Justin’s track record.
Here is what I am privately hoping for. I am honestly hoping that either Sam comes back this season right, and it is fine to walk things back with him for another season next year, or Jalen Milroe, behind the scenes, really is taking positive steps towards developing into some, and we can go different directions in the draft next year. I am honestly hoping for both of these things to be true, and I say this, again, really liking Drew Lock.
Go Hawks.








