
How different a week has made in the life of this one Seattle Seahawk fan. It was around this time last week that I decided to un-retire this blog in response to the ineptitude shown by the Seattle Seahawks offense over the course of a month.
I wasn’t just getting PTSD from the Shane Waldron days of offensive play calling, I was actually missing them due to how poorly I believed Brian Fleury was doing as the new OC with the talent that was rostered. After all, minus one certain running back, Seattle walked back the entire offense from last year, and while I was expecting some struggles adjusting to a new play caller, I hadn’t anticipated things going off the rails that profoundly awful.
In response, I un-retired this blog to put words to screen a pronouncement that, say what you will about the play caller and the quarterback, it was entirely up to John Schneider and Mike Macdonald to fix that awful mess of an offense. I won’t pretend that either Seahawk figure head even remotely knows who I am, but what I delight to see how the Seattle Seahawks came out on Sunday Night Football to handle the powerhouse Kansas City Chiefs.
Coupled with yet another stellar defensive performance, suddenly we bore witness to a Seattle offense that was perfectly acceptable, for the most part, and complimentary. Sam Darnold suddenly looked like the Sam Darnold of the past two seasons ands not his old Jets version. He was quick with the football coming out of his hands, he was accurate and decisive, and his protection was good, and he was balanced out by a very determined run game that Fleury, much like Klint Kubiak last year, stayed very committed to even with the occasional negative gain.
This is exactly the type of offense you must run with this particular starting quarterback. You can hold whatever opinion you want to have about Sam Darnold. There are many out there. I believe he is one of the more unique QBs in the game, with a wide variance between what he is extremely good at and what he struggles mightily with. This variance paints a very clear picture on what kind of offense you have got to lean into with him, if he is your starter, and is was beyond frustrating to watch Seattle for the past month and a half of football deviate so far away from it.
When Sam is under center with a heavier usage of play action mixed with occasional drop back, over that past two and a half seasons, he rates as a top five quarterback in this league, analytically, and you can look those numbers up if you don’t believe me. However, when in shotgun, in very obvious passing situations, without maximum protection, he rates as one of the worst starters in the league.
The fascinating thing about this is that play action, for many young quarterbacks coming out of college and currently in the pros, is a very hard thing to dependably do, yet here in Seattle we have one of the best to currently do it. There is one very specific style of offensive football that you must lean into with him, and that is to run the F out of the football in heavy formations coupled with quick passing and play action, and that is it. That is exactly the game Brian Fleury called for him, finally, against the Chiefs, and it could not have come at a more critical point in the season.
The analogous summary on Darnold is that he is very much the Keanu Reeves of NFL QBs. If you ask Reeves to be in an English period piece or some adapted Shakespeare for the screen type of production, it will be laughable to watch him in very unintended ways, but you ask him to carry a kick ass action film like John Wick, or the Matrix, or Speed, he’s suddenly a very watchable A list talent.
Run the f’ing football with Sam Darnold, and let the man play action off of it, and you will be able to win a lot of games with him at quarterback, especially if that style of play is matched with a great defense. As we all know, that is a very basic formula that is good enough to win a Super Bowl with.
So, yes, circling back to last Sunday night, this was a very satisfactory outing against the Chiefs who most thought would come into Lumen Field, and pulverize Darnold and company. It was so satisfactory that I felt no need to run to this blog to write about it.
It is very clear that over this mini bye after the debacle in Denver, Mike Macdonald had been thinking the same thing most of us were. We had strayed too far away from the formula of what had worked with this offense last year, and we had morphed into something that was simply not representative of the Seahawk football brand that just won a Super Bowl, and it was not a good fit for this particular quarterback. As witnessed against a very intimidating Chiefs defense, Brian Fleury mostly called a pretty solid game of offensive football, but make no mistake, this was most likely a direct result of Mike Macdonald stepping in and steering the ship back on course coming out of Denver ten days prior.
Interestingly enough, I woke up yesterday morning day feeling that it was now time for John Schneider to step up and do his part to add necessary talent. Beyond this huge matchup against the Bears on Monday night, the schedule starts to soften up for the Hawks, and it just felt right to me that Schneider needed to now make a move this week to prepare for it. I had absolutely been singularly focused at running back, and Jonathan Taylor had been in my sights for a while.
“Go get Taylor, John… just go get him.”
I have not been in the mindset to simply leave things to chance that Zach Charbornnet and Jadarian Price returning to health would be enough, and I wanted to add a true apex running back. I have been pining for this type of move for weeks, and I have not cared whether it would be an overcorrection of letting Ken Walker leave in free agency. I just wanted this type of move, badly.
In all this process, not once, had I seriously considered that the Indianapolis Colts would actually trade away All Pro offensive guard Quenton Nelson, as many fans were hoping for. From the get go, I gave it zero consideration. To understand this position is to understand the reality of this league.
Truly elite offensive guards are incredibly hard to come by these days in the pros. Most teams do not carry these sort of players and it is up to the OCs to figure out how to make do with marginal players at these positions. They are simply not being developed in college like they once were, and it can take a few years for young guys to develop into decent ones in this league.
Quenton Nelson is just not a good guard. He is arguably the very best offensive guard in the league. In other words, he is the Josh Allen of guards, the Myles Garrett of guards, and somehow, some way, he was given to Seattle for a mere third and fifth round pick. That astounds me.
If I were a Colts fan right now, I would be left with a feeling of ultimate dejection. I honestly feel for them. They have chosen to hang onto Taylor when running back is one of the easiest positions to replace and they chose to part ways with the best guard in the league when good guards are incredibly difficult these days to come by. That simply astounds me.
This move is so titanic that if I were a 49er fan who had just watched that game Seattle played on Sunday night against the Chiefs, and learned of this trade of Nelson to Seattle yesterday, I would have been left with an incredibly uneasy feeling. After all, the Niners narrowly sneaked by with a win in Seattle a couple weeks ago when Darnold was crapping down his leg in an offensive approach ill suited for him, and suddenly against the Chiefs, he looked like a much better version of himself with a heavier packaged under center physical approach. Now Seattle has added the best guard in football to this mix for a bag of chips and a can of soda pop.
I suspect there are likely many Seahawk fans who would have preferred Seattle to have traded for a premier running back such as Jonathan Taylor, and I get that. As I stated above, I really wanted Schneider to go get him after Sunday night. Let me be absolutely as clear with you as I can be on what they have chosen to do instead. I immensely prefer Quenton Nelson over Taylor, and it isn’t even remotely close.
Nelson gives Seattle a bonafide stud on the offensive line. He’s a true tone setter. He will mug you on run plays and he will stone a top tier interior pass rusher on pass downs. This is a man that is, at age 30, right in his prime to help this team win a third Super Bowl.
He is a pending free agent at the end of this season, but let me be absolutely clear about this in the following. This is a player that you do not allow to leave in free agency.
Seattle has ten games left on their schedule and a greatly increased chance at the post season to make a lasting impression on him to get a long term deal done, and they must do this. Anything short of this is inexcusable. He should be the starting left guard for the next five seasons, at least. He is that good to make sure he is kept around.
Whatever concession that they need to make to keep him here long term, they have got to make, and if they go on another deep playoff run, one of the chief concessions that he might ask for will be what the plan is at quarterback, especially if Sam trends the second half of the season towards the better version of himself. Bear this in mind, if you are resistant to Darnold getting expended in the near future.
Quenton Nelson suffered through a long revolving door at quarterback behind him ever since he game into the league with Darnold in 2018. He played as a rookie with Andrew Luck only to see him shockingly retire in his prime. They then went through a gauntlet of veteran replacements in Carson Wentz, Matt Ryan, and Phillip Rivers, and Daniel Jones, and they spent a top five pick on Anthony Richardson who has been a massive bust. None of these quarterbacks were a suitable answer and as a consequence, Indy has toiled in mediocrity.
If Seattle continues to turn this offensive ship around with Nelson’s addition to the offense line, and Darnold goes on a bit of a second half the season heater, which he is capable of doing, and they enjoy another run at some post season success, it would be understandable if Nelson and his agent would want to see Darnold as a longer termed solution at quarterback over punting on him in the future for a rookie quarterback, or kicking the tires on a Mac Jones, or Drew Lock. This is a very important thing to consider down the road for him and this franchise, but again, let me stress this to you. Seattle must figure out a way to keep this man here long term. I cannot over emphasize this position more clearly.
Now, moving on, what does this mean for Grey Zabel?
This is the fascinating question that I am eager to see answered.
It is assumed by many that Zabel will switch to right guard and Anthony Bradford will serve as a top backup. I am not a hundred percent certain of this. Say what you will about him, but Anthony Bradford provides a massive tone setting presence in the run game, and he has improved as a pass blocker. I am not so sure Seattle will want to take that aspect of his game off the field if they want to be the physically dominant team that they aspire to be.
When Zabel was coming out of the draft, he was often listed as a guard/center prospect. I can recall coming across a scouting report or two that had mentioned center as being the position that he could really excel at as a pro.
As it stands, I think he’s a good young guard. He’s not great, but he has room to grow into a top half of the league one, eventually, and it wouldn’t shock me if Macdonald choses to move him to right guard, and simply have Bradford serve as a top backup.
It would be more fascinating, however, if Macdonald and staff chose to slide Zabel into the center role, and have Jalen Sundell serve as a top reserve across the line, instead, however. There might be initial speed bumps with this transition, but this would be the move to get me most excited about the Seahawks offense this season, and beyond.
Seattle has had a premier left guard before in Steve Hutchinson, and they have had a top center in Max Unger. In all my years of following this team. They have never had a top tier guard and a top tier center playing together. The guards that played on each side of Unger during the LOB days were okay. Robbie Tobeck was a good not greater center when Hutch was opening massive holes for Shaun Alexander to run through.
If Seattle chose to move Zabel to center, they would have two incredibly imposing guards on each side of him with Nelson, and Bradford, and they would arguably have one of the strongest most athletic centers in all of professional football. Let that process in with you for a moment.
Think about the holes that would create for Zach Charbonnet who is now set to return against the Bears, and Jadarian Price, and Emmanuel Wilson. Think of the clean pocket that Sam Darnold would suddenly be afforded. Think about the tone setting that the interior of Seattle’s offensive line can provide with three big physical athletic monsters playing together inside.
I don’t know if they make this switch mid season, but Zabel to center excites my mind a lot more than simply moving over to right guard. It is about getting the three most physical players on the offensive line playing together inside.
It’s a fun thought.
When we kicked into the offseason last Spring, my desire was to see this team be active in free agency to add a quality veteran running back, and then I wanted to see this team use the draft to land another young quality guard. When free agency came and went and all they did was add Emmanuel Wilson on a very inexpensive veteran contract, I still wanted them to go guard in the first round and running back later.
Months later, we essentially have achieved the inverse of what I desired. We traded for a badass veteran guard, and we drafted an explosive running back who figures to fit in prominently to the run game once he returns from IR in short time. I will take this over what I had hoped for last Spring each and every single time.
And I get it if the average fan does not get excited about guards or defensive tackles being drafted early, or acquired for by trade. These are not exciting skill player positions. To an average fan, trading for Taylor or Saquon Barkley would have gotten their juices flowing more over the news of adding Nelson, I suspect.
The reality of football, however, is that interior lineman on both sides of the football are incredibly vital positions, and I, for one, grew very tired during the Pete Carroll years of having these spots devalued in favor of receivers, linebackers, running backs, and safeties. Eventually, Seattle had lost their way, they became soft, and in result, Carrol was dismissed from duty very unceremoniously in the face of all of his accomplishments.
We are in year three of Mike Macdonald, and we have just enjoyed a second Super Bowl victory. Under Mike, Seattle has drafted stud defensive tackle Byron Murphy in round one, and they have extended Big Cat Williams. Arguably, Seattle has the very best defensive tackle tandem in the league, and they are a huge reason for their defensive dominance.
Under Mike, Seattle has also drafted Zabel in round one, and they just traded for Nelson. My expectation is that Seattle will boast one of the absolute toughest offensive lines in football now.
Make no mistake about how this team intends to operate. We can have all the love fests we want to about JSN, Nick Emmanwori, and Devon Witherspoon, these are bright young superstar players, but the real DNA of this football team appears to be directed to the trenches. As a long time fan of this team, I cannot tell you how much that means to me.
Seattle wants to bring a physical level of dominance to the NFC West that resembles the best teams over the years that have played and one championships in the AFC North, and I have here for it. They intend to physically dominate oppositions up front, and be “shocking and relentless” behind that.
There might be another trade to be had at the deadline. Possibly a running back could still be in the mix, and I could see an edge rusher being a thing. I could also see possibly adding a decent tight end, or another receiver. For my part, with this move for Nelson, I think I would be most excited to see Macdonald add another edge rusher, and I think Khalil Mack is very much a player to watch for Seattle if they want to now throw all chips on the table for a run at the division title again.
But this was the big move. It is such a massive get for John Schneider that it just might go down as the best mid season acquisition in franchise history, and I am very careful on this blog to avoid hyperbolic assertions such as this, but this is how much I believe in Nelson coming here.
Quenton Nelson was the big fish to reel in, and short of possibly adding Maxx Crosby to the defense, I don’t know if there was a better move out there to possibly make. The 49ers, in reaction, traded for Deforest Buckner, and that was a very good move for them, but I would much rather have Nelson than Buckner in Seattle. Seattle’s interior defensive line is tops in the league. Now they have a chance at having the top interior offensive line with this move. I’m really stupid excited about that.
Last of all, I would like to leave you all with this one final thought. There was a lot of stress and hand ringing over a month ago with the Khosla Family finalizing the purchase of this team. At the time, that was perfectly understandable.
Seahawk fans have been spoiled for decades with the Allen Family owning this team, and the commitment they had shown as owners to be competitive. Under their ownership, Seattle has enjoyed the best long stretch of sports in this town, bar none, better than Husky football under Don James, and better than peak Sonics basketball in the late seventies into the nineties, and certainly better than any Mariner stretch (sorry Mariner fans).
It remains to be seen how the Khosla Fam will ultimately serve as owners of the Seahawks, but for my part, given the weight of this trade, and the fact that they signed off on this, I think these early returns are very, very encouraging. I want to give them a big shout out for this move.
Nelson is not a cheap player, and he will be very expensive to retain, but that did not dissuade them as owners. In fact, being from the Bay Area and following the Niners, they more than anyone, probably understand the impact of going and getting a top tier veteran addition to the offense line. They were in the stands as fans when John Lynch poached left tackle Trent Williams out of Washington for a third round pick. At the time, Williams was the same age as Nelson is now, and that move, perhaps more than any other one, was the one that put their offense over the top. For all we know, Neal Khosla might have been the one in Schneider’s ear, encouraging him to go get Nelson. If so, I am digging this new ownership group a whole heck of a lot better now. I will just leave you all with that final thought.
Go Hawks.








