
Well, so much for my retirement from this blog.
As those who have been regular followers of this site know, right prior to the kickoff of the 2026 NFL season, I wrote a piece that, at the time, I felt would be my final post. In that moment, it felt right for me to close out this blog. I had grown tired of laboring over it, and was more than ready to move onto other phases of life. The team, after all, had just won their second Super Bowl title, and I always try to leave a party on a high note, anyways.
So, why am I back at this thing when I was so dead set ready to move onto other things, you ask?
Well, I think the title of this post speaks for itself pretty clearly. The Seahawks offense, through six games into the season, has nose dived into such an unforeseen gawd awful mess that I actually sorta miss the Ryan Grubb and Shane Waldren days of Seahawks offensive play calling, and that is not an exaggeration.
When I wrote that final piece over a month ago, I assured Seahawks fans to not worry about this team, that it was in good hands with head coach Mike Macdonald, and GM John Schneider, that it was a bright young talented roster, and it had a talented quarterback ready to ascend to the next level of franchise QB play. Well, egg all over my face, right?
Yep.
Call me delusional if you will, but I did not foresee Sam Darnold regressing back to his old NY Jets days, and over the past two games, he is looking exactly that horrendous as a passer. In this stretch, he has looked jittery in the pocket, and unsure, and aside from the horrendous rate that he has been throwing interceptions, this is the most troubling thing to me in my mind about his play. It is not just the poor choices that has led to these turnovers, it is that fact that he appears to be having a major case of the yips, and every average fan can see this.
This is compounded by the fact that Drew Lock stepped in at quarterback during the opening game against the Patriots, when Darnold injured his butt, and played well enough for Seattle to pull off a come from behind win, and he played very well the following week against the Cardinals. In this two game stretch, Lock game managed surprisingly well, and showed the playmaking abilities of his that always has had John Schneider a bit of a fan of his.
The contrast between the play of these two quarterbacks is so sharp that it has a huge portion of the Seattle fanbase clamoring for Sam to be benched in favor of Drew. This is how well Drew Lock had played in those two games, and how badly Sam Darnold has played during the last four. Sam might still be the better quarterback of the two, but the weight of the evidence of play between these two quarterbacks this season is something that is too hard for fans to ignore.
So, why has Sam, who had such a strong showing during the playoffs and through the Super Bowl, suddenly looking like an unsure NY Jet rookie quarterback all over again?
Clearly, he is not aided by a run game that he enjoyed playing with during the second half of last year with Ken Walker, and Zach Charbonnet. In this, I will say that I was not the biggest fan of how John Schneider chose to handle the running back situation during last offseason, and the results over this past several games have only magnified what I felt was an unnecessarily risky approach to fortifying this group in the absence of the two main backs that carried much of this offense during the second half of the season last year.
I was fine enough with the decision to not pay Ken Walker, but I expected a bigger plunge in free agency with a few notable proven backs available along with using the draft to replace him. While I was fine enough with the Jadarian Price selection at the end of round one (although I preferred going guard first and then running back later), I could not shake the thought it was a highly calculated risk to rely on a rookie with Charbonnet still on the mend, and not likely ready for the first stretch of the season. Turns out that those concerns of mine were, in fact, very merited.
John gambled that Price and some scrubs would be enough to keep Seattle’s run game humming at the start of this season, and he was wrong. You can want Drew Lock as QB1 for this team right now all you want, but this is a fact that cannot be ignored. John Schneider did not do enough as the GM to properly fortify this running back room.
In result, Price, who was never the main focal RB at Notre Dame, had a hard time staying healthy through training camp, and while he flashed some very obvious skill in the first couple games of this season that helped the team to a 2-0 start, he presented Seattle another growing concern; successfully hanging onto the mother f’ing football. Even more systemic to this problem was the lack of depth behind Price.
Emmanuel Wilson would probably be a third running back option for many teams in this league and other teams, he probably wouldn’t even make their roster. George Holani would probably be a practice squad player, at best, for many other clubs. This is simply not good enough right now, without Price or Charbonnet being ready, and it shows all throughout these games.
There are worst teams in this league than Seattle who have way better running back situations. Due to the unexpected fact that the LA Rams are struggling perhaps worse than Seattle, I believe John Schneider is now absolutely duty bound to try to trade for a quality running back to help fix this offensive mess that has been created, in part, because of the huge hole on the team at running back.
The Colts are 2-4, and just fired their GM. Does this open the door for them to punt on this season and gather picks for what looks like a rich 2027 draft class? Could 27 year old Jonathan Taylor be exactly the shot in the arm Seattle needs right now? He was a Seahawks fan as a teen and outwardly expressed wanting the Seahawks to draft him the year he came out of college.
As we all know, the Eagles have the same lousy record, and seem to now be sellers for draft picks. Could Saquon Barkley be made available? He’s a bit older than Taylor and therefore, would likely demand less in turn.
Honesty, though, I think there’s a lot of teams who are lousy that have better situations are running back than Seattle does right now who merit Schneider reaching out to chat with. The Chargers, Jets, Titans, Falcons, Saints, and Bucs could all punt on this season, and offer Seattle a decent back to come in and mix with Charbonnet once he’s healthy enough to return, and Price, as well.
If Seattle swung big for Jonathan Taylor, I wouldn’t hate it. I get it that it might feel like an overcorrection for choosing not to extend K9, but so be it. I am so infatuated with Taylor that I’d even be perfectly fine offering up Price as part of the package. For Seattle to properly fix the run game and the play action passing attack that they would prefer to utilize off of it, he is the exact apex running back that is required in this style of offense, and if overpaying is something to do to get him, I’m more than okay with it.
But even in that, let us not kid ourselves, running back is not the biggest root to Seattle’s offensive struggles, and I don’t think it is necessarily Sam Darnold, either. We have to have a very serious discussion about Brian Fleury at offensive coordinator, and this is where it is within Mike Macdonald’s controls to properly fix.
When Seattle hired Fleury, they just came off a Super Bowl win, and therefore, were as late as you could possibly get in the coach hiring process. The few big named offensive play callers who had been out there, such as Arthur Smith and Frank Reich, had already taken on other gigs. It was expected that Seattle was going to hire to replace departing Klint Kubiak from within, and there were some notable candidates in run game coordinator Justin Outten (who had play calling experience and was a main reason why Seattle’s run game took off gloriously during the last stretch of the season), pass game coordinator Jake Peetz, and then QB coach Andrew Janocko.
So, it was a bit shocking that Mike Macdonald, in the eleventh hour of interviews, brought in 49er run game coordinator and tight ends coach Fleury for a visit, and then to have it quickly announced that he’d won the job through this interview. It had been talked about how he had won Macdonald over on the chalk board, and how his background with coaching on both sides of the football was a determining factor, as well.
Well, Macdonald often mentions in interviews his own pension for overthinking things, at times, in his career. Is it possible that he got caught up in overthinking this position right after the glow of winning Super Bowl LX? As of today, it sorta looks like it.
Say what you will about Sam Darnold and his regression. If he doesn’t turn things around soon, it is very obvious that he won’t be playing himself into any sort of big extension this offseason, and that is a bigger discussion further down the road. However, if you are any sort of modest student of the game, you can see a very sharp distinction between Fleury’s play calling this year to what Kubiak did for this team last season.
Under Fleury, this offense has abandoned a lot of the under center concepts that worked well with Darnold last year. On top of that, he has also steered this offense away from the heavier maximum protection looks that Kubiak used considerably more frequent. There are a lot of analytic data points that show Sam works really well under center with extra blockers, and struggles considerably more out of shotgun formations with less protection.
Why has Fleury chosen to diverge away from what had been working well enough last year? This has been the most confounding question that I have been stuck with for weeks now.
It feels as though Brian Fleury is play calling for Brock Purdy instead of Sam Darnold, and it also feels like he is play calling as if he has George Kittle and Christian McCaffrey. Seattle very clearly does not have CMC, and with all due respect to AJ Barner, they do not have anything close to Kittle, as well. Also, very clearly, Sam Darnold is probably not the quick game passing attack merchant that Brock Purdy is, and his game is really more about explosive medium and deeper shots downfield, which of course, take further time to develop, hence the probable need for more maximum protection.
So, before we can really talk seriously about benching Sam for Drew Lock, we have to have a much more serious talk about the offensive coaching. The Seahawks can satisfy the fans all that they want to by putting Drew in, but if this offensive approach does not change, I seriously doubt Drew Lock is going to have the same degree of success in this offense he did against the Patriots and Cardinals now that the league has more properly scouted out Fleury’s tendencies as a play caller.
Mike Macdonald has got to get his play caller to reign things back into what worked better for this Sam and the talent around him last season, first, and foremost, and he knows that. This is why were are not going to see Drew right now, and I suspect most of the players on this team see it very similarly to Mike. If you bench Sam now without changing the offensive approach, and Drew Lock comes in, and also struggles, you’re going to start losing the locker room. It is that simple. Players will stop trusting the coaching.
So what reasonable changes can we see to get this offense back on a good enough track to better compliment this defense, and get back to winning Seattle Seahawk football?
This is going to sound counter intuitive, but I think it is loading up with heavier fronts, and leaning more into the run. Defenses need to start fearing the run game more, and the only way you get linebackers to bite on play action is to run it right them enough. This is probably why it is critical to get Zach Charbonnet back against the Chiefs, if possible, and why I think Schneider absolutely needs to start making calls at adding another proven good veteran back.
If the Seahawks added a Jonathan Taylor or Saquon Barkley, for example, what a potentially massive shot in the arm that would be for eleven more football games left in the schedule. If linebackers and safeties have to think about a player of that quality, and then Charbonnet, and the Jadarian Price once he gets healthy enough, the whole entire play action pass tree properly opens up again, and that would play to the exact strength of Sam Darnold.
Even if they made a more modest trade for, say, Brian Robinson or Bucky Irving, one can imagine a presence such as either mixed in with Charbonnet and eventually Price would greatly improve this rushing attack. Seattle, most definitely, needs more at running back, but also, Brian Fleury needs to show a more stubborn willingness to run the football, much like Klint Kubiak showed last year when it was clear that the running attack was struggling against loaded fronts.
Brian Fleury can lean into heavier fronts and, and stubbornly run to set up play action out of them. They can do more with extra tight ends, offering Sam (or Drew if need be) more with extra blockers who can read defenders and creep out into routes and make themselves available as outlet receivers depending on what pressures defenses send their way. It feels like in 2025, AJ Barner provided good pass catching production out of heavy sets this way, and it is baffling Fleury has not used him and the other tight ends this way, or fullback Brady Russell.
Speaking of Barner, why this team hasn’t gone back to the Barn Yard play is beyond me in the most hair pulling way. To take a play that was so automatically successful out of this offense on third and short feels like sacrilege to everything we felt was their DNA last season. By not leaning into this more has neutered so much of the toughness of this team, and maybe this is the real issue with Brian Fleury. Perhaps he is just not interested in play calling a smash mouth level of offense, and this is the big massive problem with this team, presently.
Let’s be real about why Brian Fleury wanted this job. No, I do not think he was a Kyle Shanahan plant sent up here to sabotage the Seattle offense in order to help his former boss to finally win a title. Fleury, in all likelihood, saw last year what everyone else saw. He saw Klint Kubiak, who most people believed at the start of last season was a mid level offensive play caller, coach up an offense with Sam Darnold at quarterback to a Super Bowl title, and then parlay it into a head coaching gig.
Fleury most likely took this gig up here to give himself a now or never chance at creating a similar opportunity, and minus a couple running backs, he saw everything in place with this offense to do the same thing Kubiak did. They are both Shanahan disciples, after all. So, it stands to reason, in this mind set, Fleury would like nothing more than to build more of his own stamp on this offense by having Darnold do more, and show the league that he can take a second tier-ish starting quarterback, and make him even better.
This is what I believe is the most likely motivating force behind this deviation away from what Kubiak did last year. It just makes too much sense in my mind, and it has absolutely steered this offense wrong. I believe Kubiak did much better with Sam by staying true to what would best help him out, and Fleury has greatly miscalculated what Sam could do without a quality backfield and a serviceable right guard with Anthony Bradford being placed in IR.
Seattle will now likely have Bradford back against the tough task of taking on the KC Chiefs on SNF this weekend. This alone should help out this offense, but it will only help if Mike Macdonald steers his chosen play caller back towards the tough physical nature of the offense Kubiak ran last season. A remote chance of having Charbonnet back should help, as well, but again, it will only be effective with a change of offensive play calling approach.
I am not ready to predict that Seattle would win this game with a potential return of these two players, but I will say that if both players are back and Seattle’s offense leans into a more physical approach, it would give this team a better fighters chance. As the schedule breaks right now, if Seattle can at least split these next two home games between the Chiefs and Bears, and stay at 500 in the win/loss record, the second will begin to soften up some with a Cardinals and Raiders game to follow up.
Maybe by then Seattle will have added a player of note to the running back room, and maybe even another edge rusher to lean further into winning with defense the rest of the way when the schedule further softens up beyond a rematch against the 49ers. These are two moves that I really believe need to be at the forefront of John Schneider’s mind.
Mike Macdonald can do everything he can to steer this offense back to its core principles that Kubiak built up last year. He can direct Fleury to change his approach, or even replace him outright midseason with someone else on his staff who he feels will do a better job if Fleury is still not cutting it, but at the end of the day, talent is talent, and it is up to Schneider to make the mid season move or two in order to improve what is currently rostered on this team. This is a must, if Seattle wants to enjoy another post season push.
The entire NFC is up for grabs in terms of the wild card playoff spots even if now catching the winning 49ers will be a tougher challenge for Seattle. The Rams gambled heavily adding to their roster this season, and injuries have caught up to them, and they’re in a bit of a shambles. The Eagles have lost Jalen Hurts for the season to a troubling blood clot issue which may have his entire career in jeopardy. The Cowboys feel like a continual mess. The NFC South is a joke. The only division in the NFC that feels properly competitive right now in the NFC North.
It would be a real shame if Schneider choses not to be aggressive right now in the trade market. I completely get it that the 2027 NFL Draft is looking promising with some quarterbacks and other key position players, and Schneider would feel protective of having eleven draft picks next Spring, but Leonard Williams did not likely choose to sign a big extension to toil in sub 500, or mediocrity this year, and DeMarcus Lawrence did not choose to come back another season to not be making another run at a Super Bowl.
If Schneider wants to position this team to take a swing at a quarterback next year, I will understand that based on Darnold’s current play, and age, and likely salary extension demands. I can think of about six or seven college quarterbacks right now that I can envision as a potential future starting quarterback for Seattle in a Shanahan style offensive approach, if they want to go younger and cheaper at the spot around the corner.
With massive extensions looming for star defensive tackle Byron Murphy, Nick Emmanwori, and presumably Grey Zabel (even though he’s been struggling in this mess), it makes sense why they’d be reluctant to pay Sam Darnold the top end dollars he’s going to be looking for even if 2026 proves to be a down year for him. If his play vastly improves this season with proper adjustments and additions made to this offense, I can even still justify a desire for Seattle to be cautious about offering him a big extension because of these reasons mentioned.
But Seattle cannot be so transfixed on potentially drafting a future starting QB that they punt on this season when the opportunity is there to right the course of this ship and set themselves up for a playoff run. They still possess a defense that it championship worthy. Their special teams is still pretty good. They still possess talent on offense with JSN and a few others to be explosive. If they can just be more alpha at running back, and adjust this offense back to what works better for Sam, there are enough winnable games left on this schedule for Seattle to prove a massive pain in the ass for a team like San Francisco come playoff time.
Mike Macdonald, I am sure is going to act as best as he can to right the offense as best as he can, but John Schneider needs to act, as well. He sat way too passively as the GM during the offseason, and it shows through these first six games. Now it is time for him to be aggressive. I hope he does it.
Go Hawks.








